Best Selling Cat Toys

Filters and sort

Felt Heart Cat Toy Felt Heart Cat Toy
Felt Heart Cat Toy
$1.00
$1.00
  • -17% Sale
Merlot Catnip Toy
ZippyClaws Catnip Crusherz - Merlot
$4.95 $5.99
$4.95
  • -39% Sale
Rosé Catnip Toy
ZippyClaws Catnip Crusherz - Rosé
$3.60 $5.99
$3.60
  • -15% Sale
whisky plush cat toy
ZippyClaws Catnip Crusherz - Whiskey
$5.09 $5.99
$5.09
  • -29% Sale
Multipet Felt Beach Ball Cat Toy - 2.5 Multipet Felt Beach Ball Cat Toy - 2.5
Multipet - Felt Beach Ball Cat Toy (2.5")
$3.40 $4.79
$3.40
KONG Licks Kitty KONG Licks Kitty
KONG Licks Kitty
$9.99
$9.99
Cat Toy - Multicolour Wool Worm Cat 5in Cat Toy - Multicolour Wool Worm Cat 5in
Bud'Z Cat Toy - Multicolour Wool Worm
$4.79
$4.79
toy package toy top
ZippyClaws NomNomz Sushi Catnip Toys
$10.49
$10.49
  • -39% Sale
Define Planet Catnip Ball On Silver Vine Wand Cat
Define Planet Catnip Ball On Silver Vine Wand
$9.00 $14.99
$9.00
  • -39% Sale
Define Planet Catnip Activity Balls Cat
Define Planet Catnip Activity Balls
$10.20 $16.99
$10.20
  • -39% Sale
toy image
ZippyClaws Donutz Catnip Toys
$6.30 $10.49
$6.30
Jingle Bell Cat Toy Balls Jingle Bell Cat Toy Balls
Jingle Bell Cat Toy Balls
$1.00
$1.00
  • -32% Sale
Frank & Oph – Organic Catnip Bubble – 4oz
Frank & Oph – Organic Catnip Bubble – 4oz
$6.10 $8.99
$6.10
  • -20% Sale
Rattle Fish Cat Toy Rattle Fish Cat Toy
Rattle Fish Cat Toy
$6.39 $7.99
$6.39
unicorn charm zipypstick packaging
ZippyClaws ZippyStick - Unicorn
$13.99
$13.99
Slash & Meow Cat Toy
Slash & Meow Cat Toy
$3.99
$3.99