Shop Our Favourite Cat Toys

Variety of Benko Pet Foods catnip pillows in different colors and patterns, designed for hours of feline entertainment. Benko Pet Foods catnip pillow filled with 100% pure wild-grown catnip, perfect for cat playtime
Wild Catnip Pillow
$3.49
$3.49
Spring Cat Toy
Spring Cat Toy
$1.00
$1.00
YEOWWW Banana Catnip Toy YEOWWW Banana Catnip Toy
YEOWWW Banana Catnip Toy
$13.75
$13.75
Rainbow Foam Cat Ball Rainbow Foam Cat Ball
Rainbow Foam Cat Ball
$1.00
$1.00
Sheepskin Ball Sheepskin Ball
Sheepskin Ball
$1.59
$1.59
View Full Collection

Shop By Type:

Teasers & Wands
Teasers & Wands
Cat Scratchers
Cat Scratchers
Plush & Mice
Plush & Mice
Catnip & Grass
Catnip & Grass
Tunnels & Tents
Cat Balls
Cat Balls

Cat Toys

Filters and sort

  • -20% Sale
Karma Cat - Wool Christmas Holiday Cat Toy - Green Assorted
Karma Cat - Wool Christmas Holiday Cat Toy - Red and Green Assorted
$3.99 $4.99
$3.99
Outward Hound - Petstages - Wobble Turtle Catnip Diffuser Outward Hound - Petstages - Wobble Turtle Catnip Diffuser
Outward Hound - Petstages - Wobble Turtle Catnip Diffuser
$13.69
$13.69
Hauspanther Atomic Flyers Cat Toys (4pk) - Neutral Hauspanther Atomic Flyers Cat Toys (4pk) - Neutral
Hauspanther Atomic Flyers Cat Toys (4pk) - Neutral
$8.99
$8.99
Hauspanther Stacks Cat Toys (2pk) - Neutral Hauspanther Stacks Cat Toys (2pk) - Neutral
Hauspanther Stacks Cat Toys (2pk) - Neutral
$14.99
$14.99
KONG Pull-A-Partz™ Sushi Cat Interactive Toy
KONG Pull-A-Partz™ Sushi Cat Interactive Toy
$22.99
$22.99
  • -28% Sale
Turbo® by Coastal Rainbow Stack Cat Scratcher Turbo® by Coastal Rainbow Stack Cat Scratcher
Turbo® by Coastal Rainbow Stack Cat Scratcher
$34.95 $48.99
$34.95
KONG Cat Crackles Caticorn KONG Cat Crackles Caticorn
KONG Cat Crackles Caticorn
$10.99
$10.99
Hugsmart Meow Buddies Kitten Party - Carrot Cake Hugsmart Meow Buddies Kitten Party - Carrot Cake
Hugsmart Meow Buddies Kitten Party - Carrot Cake
$7.49
$7.49
KARMA CAT – 2 Pack of 1.5″ Wool Felt Balls Assorted
KARMA CAT – 2 Pack of 1.5″ Wool Felt Balls Assorted
$8.99
$8.99
Critter & Co. Pet Outpost Physical Gift Card Critter & Co. Pet Outpost Physical Gift Card $25
Critter & Co. Pet Outpost Physical Gift Card
From $25.00
From $25.00
KONG - Flingaroo Holiday Dragonfly Cat Toy KONG - Flingaroo Holiday Dragonfly Cat Toy
KONG - Flingaroo Holiday Dragonfly Cat Toy
$9.99
$9.99
  • -15% Sale
BüD'z Cat Scratching Post
Bud'Z Cat Scratching Post - Sisal And Grey Carpet for Large Cats
$84.99 $99.99
$84.99
Outward Hound® Nina Ottosson® Buggin' Out Puzzle & Play Cat Puzzle Game - Difficulty Level 2 Outward Hound® Nina Ottosson® Buggin' Out Puzzle & Play Cat Puzzle Game - Difficulty Level 2
Outward Hound® Nina Ottosson® Buggin' Out Puzzle & Play Cat Puzzle Game - Difficulty Level 2
$35.69
$35.69
  • -28% Sale
Dexypaws Plush Cat Toys - Coffee 4pc
Dexypaws Plush Cat Toys - Coffee Catnip 4pc
$12.95 $17.99
$12.95
  • -27% Sale
Dexypaws Plush Cat Toys - Cocktail 6pc
Dexypaws Plush Cat Toys - Cocktail Catnip 6pc
$15.95 $21.99
$15.95